By Colleen Tinker
One of the most consistent, carefully-managed ways Seventh-day Adventism indoctrinates its members is through its weekly Sabbath School Bible Study Guides, commonly called “Quarterlies”. Four issues of these Study Guides are published each year for each age-group within the organization. The adult Bible Study Guides are the flagship version of these studies, but Collegiate guides are also published. In addition, weekly Sabbath School lessons are distributed for high school, junior high, elementary, pre-school, and also infant—toddler ages.
Using the Sabbath School curriculum, Adventists throughout the whole world study the same lessons together every single week. Teachers Guides for each of these versions instruct those who facilitate the classes, and Adventist members all over the world, from Africa to Asia and the Americas, are taught Adventist doctrine, practice, and worldview guided by the Sabbath School Department of the General Conference in Silver Spring, Maryland.
One of the resources provided by Life Assurance Ministries is the website BibleStudiesforAdventists.com. Since 2009 this website has published weekly responses to the current week’s Sabbath School lessons. This week the lesson is entitled “Salvation and the End Time”. Since this lesson reinforced some of Adventism’s core doctrinal skews, we are running this week’s commentary on the Sabbath School lesson as a stand-alone blog.
This week addresses how the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are involved in salvation. As part of the discussion, the author asks the question, “What is the everlasting gospel”? Instead of answering the question, the author uses the Adventist great controversy worldview to explain what Adventism says Paul really means in Ephesians 1 where he talks about God’s predestination, adoption, and choice of His people.
Although the lesson addresses the love of God, the love of Christ, and the love of the Spirit, this week’s lesson also reveals the true nature of the Adventist skew of God’s sovereignty and His salvation of man. In fact, this week’s study reveals that Adventism doesn’t truly believe what the Bible says about God’s foreknowledge and choice of His people.
Who is Christ?
Before we address the issue of God’s predestination and choice, however, we must address a paragraph in Monday’s lesson: “Christ became human without any advantage over other humans. He kept God’s law, not through His internal divine power but by relying upon the same external divine power available to any other human” (p. 46).
This description of Jesus teaches Adventists that Jesus is a man with inherited propensities (to borrow a word from Ellen White) to sin just like we have. It teaches them that Jesus’ perfect life of obedience and flawless law-keeping is an example to each one of them that they, too, can keep the law as Jesus did if they just pray and depend on God enough.
This description also denies that Jesus, God the Son, could not have failed in His mission and that He could not have sinned.
Adventism teaches (as I was taught in Adventist school) that if Jesus could not have sinned, He could not have been our Savior. We had to have Someone who “had no advantage” over the rest of us, we were told, because He had to show that the law could be kept. He earned the right to die for our sins because He kept the law perfectly. It was this perfect law-keeping that made it possible for Him to be the perfect sacrifice.
If He had been unable to sin, we were taught, He couldn’t have been our Savior, because He wouldn’t have been like us.
This explanation strips Jesus of His true identity as revealed in the Bible. Jesus HAD to be the sinless Son of God, 100 percent human and 100 percent God. He did not divest Himself of His “God power” or He would not have been God. God, by definition, possess certain unique attributes including omniscience and omnipotence and omnipresence. If Jesus had not been in possession of those attributes while on earth, He could not have been God.
He gave up His glory when He came to earth. He “emptied Himself”, as Paul says in Philippians 2:7, but He emptied Himself not of being God but of His glory and His life in the heavenly realms. He did not empty Himself of being fully God with all His attributes. In fact, according to Colossians 1:17 and 19, it is Jesus’ job to have “all things hold together” in Him. If that is true—and it is—all things held together IN HIM even while He was in Mary’s womb, and even while He was in the tomb. He is ALWAYS fully God.
Moreover, Jesus was not sinless because He did not sin; rather, He did not sin because He was sinless. He was born spiritually alive, conceived by the Holy Spirit. He was not born dead in sin, a citizen of the domain of darkness as is every other person on earth. Jesus was the only person ever born who did not have to be born again.
We are born literally spiritually dead, “by nature children of wrath” (Ep. 1:1-3). Jesus, however, was born alive from the moment of conception. Although He was born into the domain of darkness, He was never a citizen of it. In a sense, God “smuggled” life into the domain of darkness in the person of His Son by sending eternal, omnipotent God in a mortal, human body to live with us and to provide the required perfect, sinless sacrifice to pay for human sin and to reverse the curse of the law pronounced on sinners.
Jesus absolutely had advantages we don’t have. He was fully God incarnate in a mortal body. In a mystery we cannot explain (because the incarnation is utterly impossible for us to understand), Jesus could not have sinned because He was God. God cannot sin. At the same time, He was tempted as a man, but there was nothing in Him that was attracted to sin, because He was sinless. He was spiritually alive and had never been spiritually dead. He Was God.
If He were any less, He could not have been our Savior. A spotless sacrifice is not merely one that manages not to sin. A spotless sacrifice is spiritually alive and never subject to the domain of darkness. He cannot be in any way deserving of the curse of sin. A spotless sacrifice does not become spotless through rigid self-denial. He is spotless because He is born alive.
The Everlasting Gospel
Thursday’s lesson leads with the question: “What is the ‘everlasting gospel?’” The author never answers the question directly but leads the reader with this response:
“The gospel is referred to here as ‘everlasting.’ This is further evidence that God does not change. An unchanging God has an unchanging gospel. This eternal gospel gives assurance to all who are willing to accept it. The gospel reveals the unchanging love of God, and it’s this message that needs to go to the world. Everyone needs a chance to hear it, which is why God has called His people to spread it” (p. 49).
Apparently the author wants the reader to think of God’s love as the definition of the gospel. To be sure, God’s love drives the gospel, but the gospel is distinct and simple. According to 1 Corinthians 15:1–4:
Now I would remind you, brothers, of the gospel I preached to you, which you received, in which you stand, and by which you are being saved, if you hold fast to the word I preached to you—unless you believed in vain.
For I delivered to you as of first importance what I also received: that Christ died for our sins in accordance with the Scriptures, that he was buried, that he was raised on the third day in accordance with the Scriptures…
Jesus’ death for our sins, His burial, and His resurrection is the gospel that we need for salvation. It is not less, and it is not more. In order to be saved, we must trust Jesus and His finished work on our behalf. If we do not admit we are hopeless sinners, if we do not repent and admit we need a Savior, we remain in our sins. If we trust Jesus and accept His blood sacrifice as the payment for our sin, our sins are transferred onto Christ.
Election
Thursday’s lesson then shifts to Ephesians 1:4-5, some of Pauls’ most powerful words about God’s sovereignty and His total authority over our salvation. Because of the way the lesson morphs the plain words of Scripture to make an Adventist point, we will quote this part of the lesson from page 49:
“Just as He chose us in Him before the foundation of the world, that we should be holy and without blame before Him in love, having predestined us to adoption as sons bay Jesus Christ to Himself, according to the good pleasure of His will” (Eph. 1:4,5, NKJV). What more does this tell us about just how ‘everlasting’ the gospel really is?
“We were chosen in Him ‘before the foundation of the world.’ Talk about an ‘everlasting’ gospel! Even before the Creation of this world, God’s plan was for us to have salvation in Him.
“Look at some of the words here: ‘chose,’ ‘predestined,’ ‘good pleasure,’ ‘adoption.’ Look at how much these two verses point to God’s desire for us to have eternal life ‘in Him.’ And the fact that God did all this in eternity past (see also 2 Thess. 2:13, 2 Tim. 1:9) points so clearly to His grace and shows that our salvation comes not from anything we can do or from any creature merit but totally as an act arising from God’s own loving character. How could salvation come from anything we could do if we were elected to have that salvation in Him even before we existed? The choice is for us to accept or reject it.
“And how is this election made manifest in the lives of the elect? To ‘be holy and without blame before Him in love’ (Eph. 1:4, NKJV). This too, is what we have been chosen for.”
Significantly, the quote above takes the clear words of Paul that God chooses, predestines, and adopts His own from all eternity and moves the reader into a confusing rationale that ends with our personal choice. Yet Ephesians is absolutely CLEAR that God’s election and choice and adoption are NOT our choices. God sovereignly chooses us.
The lesson takes two verses out of context and explains them to make a case for Adventist free will. Let’s look at those two verses in their context:
Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who has blessed us in Christ with every spiritual blessing in the heavenly places, even as he chose us in him before the foundation of the world, that we should be holy and blameless before him. In love he predestined us for adoption to himself as sons through Jesus Christ, according to the purpose of his will, to the praise of his glorious grace, with which he has blessed us in the Beloved. In him we have redemption through his blood, the forgiveness of our trespasses, according to the riches of his grace, which he lavished upon us, in all wisdom and insight making known to us the mystery of his will, according to his purpose, which he set forth in Christ as a plan for the fullness of time, to unite all things in him, things in heaven and things on earth.
In him we have obtained an inheritance, having been predestined according to the purpose of him who works all things according to the counsel of his will, so that we who were the first to hope in Christ might be to the praise of his glory. In him you also, when you heard the word of truth, the gospel of your salvation, and believed in him, were sealed with the promised Holy Spirit, who is the guarantee of our inheritance until we acquire possession of it, to the praise of his glory (Ephesians 1:3–14).
The Bible is unequivocal that God knows His own, having chosen and predestined them for adoption through Jesus. In Jesus, we who have believed have obtained (present perfect tense—we have already obtained) eternal life.
Moreover, the lesson fails even to mention Ephesians 1:13-14, either in the context of salvation or in the context of the Holy Spirit (whose role the lesson discusses on page 47, Tuesday’s lesson). These two verses explain that we KNOW we have eternal life when we believe:
In him you also, when you heard the word of truth, the gospel of your salvation, and believed in him, were sealed with the promised Holy Spirit, who is the guarantee of our inheritance until we acquire possession of it, to the praise of his glory (Ephesians 1:13–14).
When we hear the gospel (the real, identifiable gospel of Jesus’ death, burial, and resurrection for the payment of sin and the breaking of our curse of death) and believe, God SEALS us with the Holy Spirit. He is God’s promise to new covenant believers, and He comes and lives within us. He Himself is the GUARANTEE of our inheritance, our ultimate glorification.
The Teachers Comments make this confusing statement:
“Salvation cannot reach its ultimate fulfillment in this broken world, limited as it is by sinful human flesh. Therefore, salvation can happen only at the end of time. Although we are sure of salvation, all salvation depends on God, and so only the coming of Christ, at the end of days, will make the reality of salvation possible” (p. 53).
This quotation is patently false.
We can KNOW we are saved when we believe. We pass from death to life (Jn. 5:24); we are transferred from the domain of darkness into the kingdom of the Beloved Son (Col 1:13). God seals us with His Spirit who is a guarantee of our eternal inheritance. We are still here, saved souls with new hearts and born-again spirits, inside mortal bodies, but the indwelling Holy Spirit guarantees to us that our eternal future is a certainty! He is our Guarantee!
When God says in His word that He elects, chooses, and adopts us and guarantees our salvation, He means exactly that.
Concurrently, the Bible also commands us to Believe. It further tells believers to teach all things Jesus commanded and to make disciples. The fact that God is sovereign and knows and chooses His own children from all eternity does not negate our responsibility to believe when we hear the gospel.
How does this work? We cannot explain it. We only know that because the Bible tells us these things, they are all true. If we could see from an eternal perspective, these two things would not look opposed to each other. We have to live with the mystery of this unexplained reality.
God does not explain Himself to us. He reveals what we need to know in order to know Him. Our “job” is to believe, as Jesus said in John 6:29. There is no other “work of God”. And in ways God does not explain, He calls, elects, foreknows, and predestines His own to salvation. We have to believe that both perspectives are true: the God-perspective and the human perspective. Both are true, because God’s word says both are true.
Adventism, however, cannot admit that God elects and predestines His own for salvation through Jesus Christ. They must insist that we naturally have free will, and we decide whether or not to “accept or reject” salvation. A natural human, however, does not have “free will”. As people who are born dead in sin, “by nature children of wrath” (Eph. 2:3) and unable to seek, please, or honor God in any way (Rom. 3:9-15), condemned until we believe (Jn. 3:18), we have no ability to “choose” God. In fact, as our pastor Gary Inrig often says, we cannot rise about our natures. Our natures are spiritually dead and condemned to wrath and destruction. Without a miraculous act of God, we cannot choose what we do not know or have. God has to bring us to life and transfer us to His Son’s kingdom (Jn. 5:24; Col 1:13).
The Saved Are Not Sinless
Finally, Friday’s lesson (p. 50) quotes Matthew 7:21–23 where Jesus says that many will say to Jesus, “Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in Your name, cast our demons in Your name, and done many wonders in Your name?”
And Jesus will say, “I never knew you; depart from Me, you who practice lawlessness!”
The lesson says these lost people make two mistakes. The first mistake, the author says, is that they were not doing God’s will, “which was to obey His law.” The author says,
“Jesus didn’t say, ‘Depart from me’ you who were ‘not sinless,’ or you who were not ‘without fault,’ or who were ‘not perfect.’ Instead, He described them as ‘lawless’.”
The analysis of this passage completely ignores Jesus’ actual words, “I never knew you”! It is this not KNOWING that is the cause of their being lost. Knowing Jesus means being born again—a miracle that Adventism cannot explain because Adventism does not believe humans have immaterial spirits that must be brought from death to life.
Those who do not KNOW Jesus are the “lawless”. This designation has nothing to do with the Ten Commandments, which is what Adventism insists. Rather, the “lawless” are those who refuse to believe in the Son and remain under the authority of the prince of the air, the spirit now at work in the disobedient (Eph. 1:2). The lawless are those who are not living under the law of Christ. They are not hidden with Him in God (Col 3:3). They are their own authority, and they are still dead in their sin.
The lesson makes the second point that these lost ones emphasize their own works and accomplishments. Yet this point is the natural state of ALL mankind when we do not trust Jesus.
This week’s Sabbath School lesson actually ends Friday’s discussion with these words: “You want assurance? Obey God’s law and rest only in the merits of Christ’s righteousness, and you will have all the assurance you need.”
This summary is false. The way to be saved is clearly stated in Acts 16:31: “Believe in the Lord Jesus, and you will be saved,” as Paul and Silas said to the Philippian jailor.
Nowhere, not in any place in Scripture, is keeping the law part of the new covenant! Jesus, the fulfillment of every shadow of the law, has come. He has finished His work of atonement, and He is seated at the Father’s right hand in heaven.
Our marching orders are simply to believe when we hear the gospel of our salvation. The law has absolutely no part in our being saved!
The saved are those who are made alive by the Spirit when they believe in the Lord Jesus and His finished work. They are the LIVING, not the “good”, and this life means we now live under the “law of Christ” (Gal. 6:2). We are now not under the authority of earthly fathers and their discipline but are subject to the “Father of spirits” in whom we LIVE (Heb. 12:9)!
Jesus came to bring life to those whom the Father gives Him, and those whom He makes alive have new desires and a new identity.
Jesus alone is our salvation, and He knew us and chose us before the foundation of the world! †
Sources:
https://absg.adventist.org/assets/public/files/lessons/2018/2Q/TE/PDFs/ETQ218_04.pdf
For further reading:
http://www.lifeassuranceministries.org/proclamation/2012/1/hewasraisedsoyou.html
http://www.lifeassuranceministries.org/Proclamation2007_MayJun.pdf (see “Discovering the Adventist Jesus”, p. 10).
- How can I be born again? - November 14, 2024
- November 16–22, 2024 - November 14, 2024
- We Got Mail - November 14, 2024
In your article you stated: Although the lesson addresses the love of God, the love of Christ, and the love of the Spirit, this week’s lesson also reveals the true nature of the Adventist skew of God’s sovereignty and His salvation of man. In fact, this week’s study reveals that Adventism doesn’t truly believe what the Bible says about God’s foreknowledge and choice of His people.
It’s been a number of years since I spent the Sabbath at Dale and Carol’s home while they were in Peoria, AZ; but at that time I know that Dale did not hold to Reformed Theology, while he said that J. Mark was maybe a bit nearer. From the above statement, it appears that you yourself are Reformed and I’m wondering if that includes Dale as well. Or am I reading too much between the lines? It seems any skew on God’s sovereignty would be Arminianism, a real problem for the Reformed view regarding God’s election to salvation and those He did not and for both saved and unsaved, God is to be given glory due to Him being sovereign contrasted to the fact that we are not.
Karl, we are not “Reformed” in any defined way. Neither are we Arminian. In fact, we are repeatedly “accused” by some of being too Reformed, while others insist that we are too Arminian. Dale, Richard, and I all are committed to teaching what Scripture says about God’s sovereignty and His will in any context the Bible presents them.
The Bible clearly states things which cannot be resolved by reasoning or playing with definitions. As I explain farther into the article:
“Concurrently, the Bible also commands us to Believe. It further tells believers to teach all things Jesus commanded and to make disciples. The fact that God is sovereign and knows and chooses His own children from all eternity does not negate our responsibility to believe when we hear the gospel.
“How does this work? We cannot explain it. We only know that because the Bible tells us these things, they are all true. If we could see from an eternal perspective, these two things would not look opposed to each other. We have to live with the mystery of this unexplained reality.”
Adventism, however, deviates from the spectrum of Arminianism, which is a secondary issue within Christianity, and is more nearly Pelagian. Adventism insists that man has a completely free will to choose and do whatever he wishes—a will which even God must honor by limiting His own sovereignty.
The Bible, however, states that we are born dead in sin (Eph. 2:3) and unable to please, seek, or honor God (Rom. 3:9-15). We cannot “rise above our own natures”, as our pastor Gary Inrig often says. Jesus even said we are condemned if we have not believed (Jn. 3:18). In other words, the condemnation is our natural condition, not a condition we reach if we choose not to believe.
Consequently, God must intervene in order to give us the ability to hear the gospel and to believe. How all of this works I cannot explain. What I realize, though, is that we must believe what the Bible says about these things. If it clearly teaches both our natural depravity and deadness AND our responsibility to believe when we hear the gospel of our salvation (Eph. 1:13), then both are true. I must live with this tension, or this “unresolvable” dichotomy. God truly IS sovereign and is bigger than all we can see!
No, we refuse to fight the internal battle of Reformed theology versus Arminianism. We at Life Assurance Ministries are committed to teaching what the Bible says in every context as we read. What we oppose is the Pelagian viewpoint which shapes Adventism. We at Life Assurance Ministries believe that God is sovereign over salvation, and He is the One who brings us to Himself and gives us life. We do not save ourselves in any sense!
Colleen Tinker, Your first two points are right on target, but please refrain from explicitly or implicitly condemning those of us “formers” who do not fall into your preferred Calvinist-reformed category of the only elect and predestined for salvation. I do not for one minute believe that God closes the door to salvation for anyone simply because he has foreknowledge as to who will ultimately be saved and who will not. God calls us all to repentance and then supplies us with faith to respond to and accept his grace. Our free will choice to believe and depend wholly on Jesus Christ is no more a “work” than receiving information and understanding its significance. God created us with rational minds and intelligence and yes he created us all with a free will. If not we are not responsible for what we do in life and that kind of god is one who created evil and is a monster. I do not worship that Calvinist God!
AD, I agree with you; God does NOT close the for to salvation for anyone simply because he has foreknowledge as to who will ultimately be saved and who will not. We are 100% responsible for our decisions and their consequences.
Romans 1:18-22 even states that what can be known about God’s eternal nature and divine power is clearly seen, but men suppress the truth with their wickedness. All are without excuse.
The biblical picture of our sovereign God is much, much bigger than any mortal mind can explain. He is fully sovereign and knows us before we are born. He knows every one of our days before any of them come to be, and the names of the saved are written in His book. We are born spiritually dead and cannot seek, know, or please God unless He intervenes.
And yet…we are commanded to believe. We are responsible for our decisions. Judas, even though Jesus said he fulfilled Scripture, is fully responsible for his treachery.
How does this work?
I do not know. Scripture does not reveal how these two apparently opposed things can both be true. But because Scripture teaches both, we are obligated to take God seriously and believe what He says. When we are convicted of truth, we must believe and trust Him. At the same time, we can know that nothing is outside of His sovereign control. Even evil is a subset of creation. God ultimately is responsible for all that occurs.
If we try to resolve these apparent paradoxes which Scripture describes, we end up with a heresy. We have to live with the tension of knowing both are true even though we can’t explain how that works.
But then, if we could explain it, we’d understand God! It’s actually comforting to me to know that I can trust Him in every situation and know that He is the one who keeps us and equips us and wastes nothing that happens to us but redeems everything we submit to Him! And I know that He holds me responsible for submitting and believing Him, for obeying His word when I feel outraged or helpless.
It’s a “both-and”, and I don’t understand it. I do know that the longer I embrace both realities, the less confused I feel even though I have NO idea how to explain it!
PS–one more thing….in John 6 the Jews were asking Jesus what they needed to do in order to do the work of God. His answer in verse 29: “This is the work of God, that you believe in Him whom He sent.” Believing is God’s work which He commands of us, and it’s also the work He does in us. But we are not free to rise above our natures. As spiritually dead natural humans, we cannot rise about that death. We have to have the intervention of God, and then we can respond to Him. We are truly free only after we have received His eternal life. Until then, we are dead, and dead people cannot live without a miracle.